Minutes of the Meeting of the Planning Committee on Monday 18th March 2019
PRESENT: Cllr Wright, Williams, Haywood, Ashdown, Higgs
Also present: D/Cllr White
Apologies for absence: None
Absent without apologies: Cllr Rowton-Lee
Co-option of temporary committee members to be agreed: None
Declarations of Interest: None
Public Question Time: No public were present
Bovis Homes – Show home open. Planting completed with mature, 6ft hedging.
A2 Dominion / NK Homes –Show home open. Still waiting on details regarding allotment area – CPC has chased for alternative details.
Bloor Homes – New road layout to be completed in phase 2 and 3 – suggested dates are from 20th May – a meeting to be arranged for late March to discuss options on site with all parties involved.
Bellway Homes – New pavement works to be completed once SSE remove old lamp posts – CPC and OCC chasing for a completion date.
Taylor Wimpey – The Carriages - nothing to report
Taylor Wimpey – OKL – CPC following up on land ownership with TW to get clarification as to the current status of land owners.
Persimmon Homes – Meeting to be re-scheduled asap.
CPC has requested directly to all developers and also OCC to remove some of the yellow directional developers signage – these signs contravene Highway Act 1980 and are excessive in Chinnor.
OCC gave CPC written permission to remove all except Chiltern View (as they have permission)
Planning applications considered:
Application Ref: P19/S0568/HH
Proposal: Amendments to application reference P18/S3919/HH. First floor front extension (walls to be brick), first floor rear extension, single storey side and rear extension, change side door to window. Demolition of existing garage. Alter porch canopy to front.
Address: 1A Oakley Lane
CPC Recommendation: No Objection
Application Ref: P19/S0510/FUL
Proposal: Construct new dwelling
Address: 2 Manor Farmhouse, Henton
CPC Recommendation: No Objection with comments
1) CPC fully supports the OCC Highways concerns and holding objection
2) CPC fully supports the SODC Planning Officers recommendation, if minded to refuse.
3) Concerns over the dwelling being an over development of area, un-neighbourly and detrimental to rural setting.
Application Ref: P19/S0525/FUL
Proposal: Addition of three new Philips OptiVision 2000w luminaires mounted onto the rear of 2 existing 15m lighting columns for the main floodlit pitch.
Address: Chinnor Community Pavilion
CPC Recommendation: Fully Support
Lights will be off by 10pm at the latest when in use
Not to be used every evening, 7 days a week
Lights for use when football training only – not when parties or events of any kind are being held in the Pavilion
Application Ref: P19/S0237/HH
Proposal: A wooden car port and garage in front of the house
Address: 20B Oakley Road
CPC Recommendation: No Objection
Application Ref: P18/S1674/O Amended details
Proposal: Demolition of existing kennels. Redevelopment of site to provide 5 dwellings with access (as revised by plans dated 12-12-18 and 14-03-19 to clarify impact on trees and landscaping opportunities on site)
Address: Former Forest Glade, now Chinnor Hill Kennels
CPC Recommendation: No Objection – comments as before – as listed on SODC page.
The report was noted but our comments remain the same.
Application Ref: P19/S0690/LB
Proposal: Replace existing leylandii hedge between The Poplars and October Cottage with brick wall.
Address: The Poplars, Crowell Road
CPC Recommendation: No Objection with comments
1) Ensure OCC Highways have agreed with wall geometry
2) Ensure all materials used are in keeping with surrounding area
Certificate of Lawful development application – for information
Application Ref: P19/S0679/LDP
Proposal: Proposed single storey rear extension
Address: 12 Doveleat
7. Planning Permission Granted by SODC
Application Ref: P19/S0130/HH
Proposal: Front, rear and side two storey extension. Single storey extension to rear.
Address: 9 Flint Hollow
Application Ref: P19/S0228/HH
Proposal: Single storey rear extension and single storey front porch extension.
Address: 19 Orchard Way
Application Ref: P19/S0105/HH
Proposal: Front extension and rear extension to existing detached annexe and new dormer window in existing roof.
Address: Ash Wain Cottage, Wainhill
Application Ref: P19/S0030/HH
Proposal: Remove existing conservatory and construct 2 storey rear extension. Single storey front and side extension. Demolish garage (as amended by plans)
Address: 37 Cherry Tree Road
Application Ref: P19/S0027/HH
Proposal: Single storey rear extension and first floor extension over garage. Replace remainder of garage flat roof with pitched tiles (as amended by plans)
Address: 4 Rectory Meadow
Application Ref: P18/S3881/FUL
Proposal: Variation of condition 1 – approved plans of reserved matters for 78 dwellings
Address: Land adj Mill Lane School
Application Ref: P19/S0099/HH
Proposal: Erection of a triple garage
Address: The Croft, Chinnor Hill
Approval of reserved matters
Application Ref: P18/S3194/RM Amended Details – Information Only
Proposal: Reserved Matters application for approval of the appearance, landscaping, layout and scale of one detached two storey dwelling. following outline planning permission P16/S0699/O for the erection of a detached dwelling with garaging and associated amenity space and separate garage and pedestrian access for No.1 Lower Icknield Way with all matters reserved except for access (dwelling changed from four to three bedrooms and depth of rear projection reduced, parking spaces serving new dwelling reduced from three to two and garage to No.1 amended to allow access through as shown on amended plans received 4th February 2019).
Address: Land rear of 1 Lower Icknield Way
8. Planning Refusal Decision made by SODC
Application Ref: P18/S1759/FUL Amended Details
Proposal: Erection of 9 dwellings and re-siting of employment use on site (as amended by plans received 31 July 2018 proposing wildflower meadow and landscape planting, and plans received 6 August 2018 extending internal access road to enable large vehicles to turn, widened access onto Thame Road and associated revised building layout including relocation of Plot 1 further to the north west, and air quality report received 3 September, and tree removal information received 21 September 2018, as amended by site layout plan 485.10E received 30 January 2019 to address highway concerns / include footways within and to the site).
Address: Land west of Thame Road
9. Planning Matters
9.1 To note recent enforcement cases opened and currently being investigated:
SE18/730 – development on Mill lane for A2 Dominion – plots 74-77 not being constructed in accordance with approved plans – levels are too high. SODC are waiting to borrow height calculating equipment before they can proceed with investigations.
SE18/733 – development on Mill Lane for A2 Dominion – plot 8 not being built in accordance with approved plans as too high. SODC are waiting to borrow height calculating equipment before they can proceed with investigations.
SE18/738 – 3 Riders Way – erection of a fence on open plan frontage causing visual difficulties to motorists – without permission. Resident has now been written to and they are submitting a retrospective planning application - P19/S0647 (new application)
SE18/742 – Doves, Sprigs Alley – caravan being used as a permanent dwelling without permission – Case closed – Not expedient
SE18/710 - Without advertisement consent display of illuminated signs (non-compliance with details approved under advertisement consent P18/S2934/A (non-illuminated). At Bovis Homes site. Case Closed – No Breach
9.2 Addition of property name – Bellwood House to the commercial property – 57 Lower Road.
9.3 Letter from Archstone Projects Ltd regarding the status of land which was dismissed at appeal for Cala Homes – The Clerk to respond to the letter explaining that CPC do not wish to meet as this land is not in the Neighbourhood Plan, is outside the village boundary, is not in the SODC Local Plan, and to state the recent refusal reasons for the Thame Road application.
9.4 A letter to be written to John Howell MP offering full support from CPC with regard to the Private Member's Bill Planning (Appeals) Bill 2017-19 = Henley Constituency.
10. Chinnor Neighbourhood Plan – Review 2019
10.1 Chinnor Parish Council Planning Committee discussed the CNHP Review –
Cllr Williams reported on the dateline and process to follow and public consultation dates. NHP Review documents will be available in various places from mid May.
Cllr Wright thanked the committee for all of their hard work to get to this point.
Cllr Haywood proposed to formally accept the review of the Chinnor Neighbourhood Plan. Seconded by Cllr Higgs. All in favour.
Chairman _________________________________________ Dated ________________
( 34KB )